Nothing New Reviews

Nothing New has an overall rating of 4.1 based on 25 reviews. Customer feedback on Nothing New is mixed: Nothing New reviewers highlight positive aspects like sustainable materials, stylish designs, comfortable fit, excellent customer service, which strongly appeal to eco-conscious consumers, fashion-forward individuals, millennials and Gen Z. However, Nothing New is often criticized for its higher price point, limited size range, occasional shipping delays, lack of variety in styles.

4.1/5.0

25 reviews

5 Stars

13

4 Stars

2

3 Stars

10

2 Stars

0

1 Star

0

All Nothing New Reviews (25)
Richard-preskar
May 21, 2026
"Easy enough to clean, but maybe not as much as expected"
I mean, they do look really nice, and for the most part they’re easy to wipe down after regular wear. The outside cleans up fine, so that part is good. But the fabric areas take a little more effort, and even then they don’t always look totally clean, if that makes sense? Maybe I was expecting too much for everyday shoes, but I thought they’d be a bit easier to keep looking fresh. Overall, not bad, just kind of average when it comes to cleaning
KerrieLeon_73
May 15, 2026
"I really like how these shoes look…"
I really like how these shoes look, and they’ve been fine for short walks or quick errands. My sister actually complimented them the first time I wore them. That said, the comfort wasn’t quite what I was hoping for. The soles felt a bit stiff at first and definitely needed some time to break in. They’re not painful, just not something I’d want to wear all day. I still grab them occasionally, but I probably wouldn’t choose them for a long day out.
hello_preston441
May 08, 2026
"Showed Up Shockingly Fast!"
I was not expecting it to arrive that quickly — I was practically shocked when it showed up at my door already! The box was in good shape too, so no complaints at all. Super happy with how smooth everything went
andreawalczak0314
May 06, 2026
"Scuffed up a little faster than expected"
The shoes look good and they fit fine, so no complaints there. But the scuff resistance is kind of average. I wore them around the city a few times—nothing crazy, just normal walking, and I already noticed some marks on the toe area. They’re definitely still wearable and don’t look ruined, but I’d assume they’d hold up a bit better with regular use.
Teresa_deal81
April 30, 2026
"I picked up a pair from..."
I picked up a pair from Nothing New because I liked the clean, simple look and figured they’d be an easy everyday shoe. At first, everything seemed promising, like the start of a very chill sneaker success story.

They’re comfortable enough for walking around, but the breathability is where the drama begins. After a few hours, especially indoors or on a sunny day, my feet start feeling noticeably warm, like they’re trapped in a tiny sneaker greenhouse.

They’re definitely still wearable and not painful or anything, but I wouldn’t choose them for a long day out. Fine overall, just not as airy as I hoped. I’d give them 3 stars.
Anna-polk
April 26, 2026
"Had my Nothing New shoes for months and…"
Had my Nothing New shoes for months and they’re still in great shape. I wear them all over the city, and they haven’t started falling apart at all. Soles still good, stitching’s fine, and dirt cleaned off easily. better durability than I expected.
Erin.hatcher
March 18, 2026
"Worth It Overall"
I didn’t have a ton of time to overthink this and felt a bit rushed when I decided to go for it, but I’m glad I did. It ended up being worth it, and I really don’t have any complaints.
JuliaHickey_72
March 08, 2026
"Checkout was actually easy and…"
Checkout was actually easy and everything went through without any issues, which was nice. But then the shipping info was kind of confusing and I wasn’t totally sure what to expect. Not a huge deal, but also a little frustrating.
hello_heather013
March 05, 2026
"Grip is decent, but the attitude wasn’t great"
The traction is okay overall, but it definitely slips a little on wet floors. I mentioned it and kind of felt talked down to, like I just didn’t know what I was talking about. It’s not terrible, just not as impressive as I expected.
hello_gregg220
February 24, 2026
"I wore these for a full day and..."
I wore these for a full day and was surprised that the laces stayed tied the whole time. They felt sturdy and held up really well, which made them easy to forget about in a good way.
hello_john050
February 21, 2026
"I ordered from nothingnew.com and, from what I…"
I ordered from nothingnew.com and, from what I remember, everything went smoothly. I’m a little fuzzy on the small details, but I do remember the delivery showed up exactly when they said it would, which was nice. The tracking updates were helpful too. Box arrived in good shape, no strange delays or anything. Overall, happy with the experience.
jamestade2429
February 12, 2026
"Nice shoes, exchange took a bit"
The shoes were actually really nice, but something about it just didn’t fit quite right for me size-wise. I was able to exchange them, which was good, but the process was a little slow and I had to follow up once. Not a terrible experience, just wish it was a bit easier.
clintonmisnick4706
February 09, 2026
"Easy to Find What I Needed"
I was glad they actually had the color and size I wanted in stock. A lot of other sites seem to be sold out all the time, so I appreciated not having to keep checking back or settle for something else. To be fair, it was a straightforward order, but that’s kind of what made it a good experience. I found what I wanted, ordered it without any hassle, and moved on.
JamesOlsen_56
January 27, 2026
"I wore these during a heavy rainstorm..."
I wore these during a heavy rainstorm and my feet stayed dry the whole time. I’d seen a few people mention they were good in wet weather, they were right...
sonya1977
January 17, 2026
"Surprisingly solid fabric"
I’ve only used it a bit so far, but the fabric feels really good—soft enough to be comfortable, but still sturdy like it won’t wear out fast. i was relaxed about it at first, and then I touched it and was like, wait, this is actually nice.
Sean_johnson71
January 13, 2026
"Took a Little Breaking In"
At first they felt a bit stiff and I wasn’t totally sure I was going to love them but after wearing them around for a while they started to loosen up and feel much more comfortable, so now I’d say they’re comfy once you give them a little time to break in.
joni-Mckenzie
January 05, 2026
"I had to wait a few…"
I had to wait a few days before I got a reply, which was frustrating. To be fair, they did sort the issue out in the end, but it definitely wasn’t quick. If the response time is like this again, I’d probably think about taking my business somewhere else
Adam.miller
January 04, 2026
"Arrived in Good Shape"
The box came in good condition, so I’m thinking it was handled well, right? No issues that I noticed...
Josephine_lumukanda86
January 03, 2026
"Glad I finally found vegan shoes"
I ended up ordering from nothingnew.com because I’d been trying to find shoes that were actually vegan, and of course I waited until I really needed a new pair to start looking. Bad timing on my part, but I’m glad I found them. I like that the brand is upfront about not using leather, and the shoes actually look nice too. They were a little stiff at first, but after wearing them a bit they got comfortable. Overall I’m really happy with them and would definitely buy again.
William.michel
January 03, 2026
"I ordered these from nothingnew.com and the..."
I ordered these from nothingnew.com and the first thing I noticed was how light they felt. I was expecting something a bit heavier, kind of like my old sneakers, but... yeah, not at all. They’re not bulky, easy to wear around all day, and my feet haven’t felt tired so far...

View More Reviews

Have a question about Nothing New?

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.